Buying a Home Again After Years of Renting
Can You Be a First Time Buyer If You’ve Owned a Home Before?
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.
A fee of up to £495 per mortgage may be charged depending on individual circumstances.
The information contained within was correct at the time of publication but is subject to change.
3rd November 2026
When most people hear the words “first time buyer”, they assume the definition is simple, you’ve either owned a property before or you haven’t. From a mortgage perspective, however, it isn’t always quite that straightforward.
I recently helped Fiona, a mum of two who I’ve got to know over the last couple of years. She had previously owned a property with the father of her children but had been renting for several years. She was now ready to buy a family home of her own.
Although Fiona had owned property before, the length of time since she had last been a homeowner meant that some mortgage lenders were prepared to treat her as a first time buyer for their mortgage products.
Starting again after several years of renting
Fiona was in a strong position.
She had a good income from her sales role, made up of a basic salary alongside bonus and commission, very little debt and a clean credit history. She also had a healthy deposit available from the sale of the previous family home.
The plan was to buy a lovely semi-detached family home in a leafy suburb, where Fiona and her two children could settle for the foreseeable future.
Her priorities were straightforward. She wanted to know exactly what her mortgage payment would be each month so that she could budget confidently, and she wasn't planning on moving again any time soon.
Looking beyond the obvious mortgage options
One of the most important parts of mortgage advice is understanding how different lenders interpret a client's circumstances.
Fiona wasn't a first time buyer in the everyday sense because she had owned a property previously. However, some lenders have their own definitions when determining eligibility for particular mortgage products.
Because she hadn't owned a property for several years, we were able to consider lenders that could potentially treat her as a first time buyer again for mortgage purposes.
That was particularly useful in this case.
Some of the first time buyer options available provided enhanced affordability, allowing eligible borrowers to potentially borrow significantly more than under the lender's standard affordability criteria. In Fiona's circumstances, we were able to consider an option allowing borrowing of up to around six times income, subject of course to the lender's full affordability and eligibility assessment.
The first time buyer product we ultimately considered also included cashback, which provided a useful contribution towards the inevitable costs that come with moving home.
Why we chose a five year fixed rate
The mortgage itself didn't need to be overly complicated. Fiona wanted certainty. This was intended to be a long term family home, rather than somewhere she expected to leave after a couple of years. Having a predictable monthly payment was also important to her.
For those reasons, I recommended a five year fixed rate mortgage.
It meant Fiona would know what her mortgage payment was going to be each month throughout the initial five year period and wouldn't need to worry about short term changes in mortgage rates affecting her payments.
It also avoided choosing a shorter deal simply for the sake of it and then having to review the mortgage again in two years.
A straightforward application and a great result
We ultimately proceeded with a high street building society and had a fantastic experience.
The application itself was very straightforward, but the real value came from identifying the right lender and understanding how their criteria applied to Fiona's circumstances.
By being treated as a first time buyer for the mortgage product, Fiona was able to access a more attractive option than if we had simply approached the case on the basis that she was an existing homeowner. It also provided additional borrowing capacity and cashback towards the costs of moving.
Most importantly, she was able to secure the family home she wanted, with a mortgage structured around the stability and predictability she had asked for from the outset.
Owned a property before? Don't automatically rule yourself out
If you've owned a home previously but have been renting for the last few years, don't assume that every mortgage lender will automatically treat you in the same way as an existing homeowner.
Depending on how long it has been since you owned a property and the lender's individual criteria, you may qualify for mortgage products specifically designed for first time buyers.
That can potentially mean access to different rates, cashback incentives or enhanced affordability, depending on the lender and your circumstances.
There is an important distinction though, being treated as a first-time buyer by a mortgage lender doesn't necessarily make you a first time buyer for Stamp Duty Land Tax purposes. If you've owned residential property previously, different rules can apply, so this needs to be considered separately.
If you've owned a property before but have been renting for several years and are now thinking about buying again, it's worth getting advice before assuming which mortgage options are available to you.
Speak to Bristol Rose Mortgages and we can look at your circumstances, compare the available lenders and establish what you could potentially borrow.